Mobile Payments – Ten Years on, What Has Changed?

When in 2004 Globe Telecoms of the Philippines launched its G-CASH product as a competitor to the successful cash switch released in 2000 by way of Smart, the other cell operator in the Philippines, it appeared clean that it turned into only a depend of time before cellular payments and cell banking became a chief a part of the way wherein negative people obtained financial offerings. The MicroSave-Microenterprise Access to Banking Services (MABS) M-Banking Dialogue 2009 held in Manila, precipitated a few reflection on what has modified in ten years in the m-banking surroundings. This Briefing Note considers a number of the key developments.

Platform / Protocol In the early days of mobile bills, two fundamental troubles worried ability companies. Would there be coverage inside the regions where the unbanked and capability customers will be located? And what packages/communications should the handsets support? It turns out that they ought to have been extra involved approximately enterprise fashions, and consumer price propositions.

american-express-89024.jpg (1280×803)

The coverage issue has in large part disappeared, at the least for international device for cellular conversation (GSM) services. Few might-be mobile fee service carriers now appear involved over insurance. In most low profits markets widespread packet radio services (GPRS) offerings are now available and 3G has been released or is predicted. Network reliability can also nevertheless purpose difficulty, but might be no more an obstacle to operations, than different infrastructure constraints automatically confronted in far flung regions (power cuts, bad roads etc). In fact in many countries the mobile conversation networks have proved the maximum resilient in instances of disaster. The evolution of the handset is extra difficult to song, however is absolutely converting unexpectedly. Three tendencies seem relevant. Figure 1 highlights the extent to which more and more telephones are “more desirable” – by way of which we imply able to manage over the air application downloads using GPRS.


One of the principle worries ten years in the past changed into the problem component skilled whilst clients needed to download an application the use of subscriber identity module (SIM) toolkit. In fact most early answers requiring menu downloads or for customers to don’t forget lengthy “strings of numeric codes” have been no longer commercially successful, and created an asymmetry among the segments centered and reached. Although concentrated on the unbanked, it become in large part the banked and literate who had been able to manipulate the down load procedure and the unbanked want devoted assistance and help to manage this procedure which dramatically elevated the prices of launching a service.

With more cutting-edge handsets, a dramatic fall in the costs of handsets, java packages, GPRS services (and an increasingly more technologically-conscious marketplace) these problems seem largely to were resolved for lots customers. Of identical concern was the capability of the SIM playing cards issued with the aid of cellular operators to address the additional applications. Although little information is to be had evidently most networks have efficaciously migrated maximum customers to 64k SIM playing cards within the ordinary course of business, hence eliminating the constraint and additionally casting off the want for clients to finish a potentially complicated SIM switch to avail of a mobile charge provider.

The 0.33 trouble concerns safety, with operators needing to make alternate-offs between ease of deployment and use and security. These troubles stay and stay a key characteristic of debates on the perfect enterprise model and partnerships required to be triumphant. There are actually in all likelihood three companies of “middle solutions” and associated business models that are competing within the marketplace, which mirror those trends:

i) SIM dependent and included answers – The pleasant know instance of such an answer is M-PESA from Safaricom, which is now pre-loaded on all new Safaricom SIM playing cards. Being incorporated into the SIM card, the answer can operate, and become designed to function, on the most simple cellphone, and has to give up-to-cease encryption. However given the degree of technology integration this form of answer is extraordinarily tough for a non-cell community operator (MNO) to offer and therefore gives an MNO a large gain over other cellular payments providers, and is, for this reason, a central characteristic of MNO lead enterprise fashions.

Ii) USSD answers – similarly a success are solutions that use unstructured supplementary carrier statistics (USSD) and simple menus to provide cell price answers. Bank cell payment carriers in South Africa have seen the best success with USSD

services. However as the preliminary leg of the transaction is not encrypted or comfortable, most of these offerings had been limited to “closed loop transactions” – wherein cash is exceeded between debts or users at a single financial institution, but no longer among banks. This is a large constraint to reaching full-size use of mobile bills as interactions can be restrained to both the bank’s personal clients and out of community bills want to be to cash. As all phones can use USSD, the answer can attain big target segments, and because the USSD provider does no longer require integration with the SIM card, these offerings can be released with minimum involvement of a MNO. Although the MNO wishes to agree to make the service to be had and this has been a trouble in a few markets. In USSD answers every body can “play” and banks have tended to be the winners.

Iii) GPRS/Java answers – involving downloads. As noted above downloading solutions to an “enhanced” cellphone is extensively less complicated, and increasingly more human beings have higher first-rate phones, or soon may have them. It is probably that the majority who are banked now have telephones which could take care of such downloads. This business model is possibly the maximum contestable as the downloadable utility may be from a financial institution, mobile community operator or any other 0.33 party. The downside stays that the solution is not any extra at ease than getting access to the net, and to compensate the company for the associated danger transaction costs generally tend to better.

What Might The Future Hold? The destiny industry terrain might be governed by means of trouble of customer possession and platform. Whereas the cell operators will keep having the best herbal marketplace share and brands, their capacity to use this to fasten clients into services and products they offer will likely decrease. In the cutting-edge weaker worldwide market conditions, and with even some rising markets achieving saturation inside the mobile telephone market, it appears possible that the cost of more suitable telephones will keep to fall, and their penetration will preserve to upward thrust. Over time, and as befell with the internet, this may deliver more advantage to whoever has the nice utility and advertising marketing campaign to get the utility directly to the person’s telephone or to draw them to their cellular enabled internet site. In this admire the statement that Nokia phones will in destiny include a pre-loaded Nokia cash solution that enables a few shape of card to card fee.


Troublemaker. Wannabe music fanatic. Beer aficionado. Devoted food junkie. Twitter fan. Freelance thinker.Won several awards for analyzing sheep in Cuba. Spent 2002-2009 promoting action figures in the UK. What gets me going now is getting to know pond scum in the UK. Won several awards for investing in toy soldiers on the black market. Spent several months getting my feet wet with spit-takes in Gainesville, FL. Spent 2002-2009 testing the market for tobacco in the aftermarket.